The United States’ Nativist Tone is Neither New nor Unique

/“Daniel Restrepo, senior fellow at the Center for American Progress and former Western Hemisphere advisor to President Barack Obama; Jacob Soboroff, NBC News and MSNBC correspondent; and Roberto Suro, professor of journalism at the USC Annenberg School and scholar of US immigration policy, examine progressive, humane visions for border control and immigration policy. Moderated by Univision journalist and Slate columnist León Krauze.”

On Wednesday April 17th, Moderator León Krauze started off by characterizing Trump as having, “become something never before seen quite like this in American political life: an outright nativist president”. He posits this forum around the question: How should democrats respond, and if it is simply enough to be against Trump.

We have three panelist who are on the liberal side of today’s agenda. They all are against even trying to logically confront Donald Trump. Instead, there’s conversation over nationalistic identities, deterrents, and the brokenness of the American deportation and immigration systems.

Roberto Suro says it doesn’t matter who the target of hatred is, “it’s a matter of self-identity” … “it’s a measure of insecurity” by the republicans in order to protect their privileges and bloodstained lands. However, this ends the conversation with blame placed and little clarification on what repercussions the people who are antagonizing migrants should go through, or what that healing process might be like. These conversations don’t go deeper because many allies have started to look at immigration as something second to universal healthcare, to universally equal benefits. Restrepo brings up Nancy Pelosi’s directive for the democratic party to stay within a certain set of topics. Pelosi pleads to stay focused on the issues which she believes will allow democrats to win. This may seem like they are trying to do good – at all costs, but at the same time they are actively engendering a system which continues to ignore immigrant issues further silencing the already conspicuously quieted voices of those marginalized communities that have less say in government matters.

How are democrats overall responding? In many cases it seems democrats are agreeing with Pelosi. March 26th, democrats in the house from all over joined Pelosi’s call to “stay focused on our purpose ‘For the People’ — lower health-care costs, bigger paychecks and cleaner government.” They shirk away from acknowledging the issues of less-represented people and lower-regarded issues. On the other hand, republicans are weaponizing the issue of immigration, causing malcontent and resentment, which leads to further polarization of people and also seeks to inflame the Republican base voters by appealing to their fears. Krauze brings up that about two thirds of republicans believe immigration is the more dire issue in the country. While one side of politics screams at immigrants with hate, the other attempts to gain their own prosperity without defending those under siege. Even if done with the best intentions of wanting to assume control in order to then help, watching it play out in real time it is difficult to get past the gurlessness of it.

Each of the speakers agreed that the way politicians are going about immigration is wrong. Soboroff and Restrepo spoke of the deterrents put in place at the border, and although they have been effective in lowering the official tallies of unauthorized immigration over the border, they have also increased the number of deaths occurring when crossing over.

I turn to Gloria Anzaldua’s Chicana feminism to point out that “[w]here there is persecution of minorities, there is shadow projection.” (Anzaldua, 108) The hatred is internalized, and then projected. By keeping a classist and xenophobic system it’s easier to see the immigrant as not only different than ones self, but also lower than ones self. This pathological need to “other” new waves of immigrants stems from the insecurity of belief in the ‘American dream” ideal. As Suro points out, the nativist feelings of America have gone back to the core. Since John Adams, since the Chinese Exclusion Act, etc. Similarly, the history of liberals progressing their own needs, like healthcare, can be made to be seen as “For The People”, regardless of issues involving outside threats and internal conflicts. Los gringos must learn to listen, even after their savior complexes are fulfilled.

The biggest agreement that the panel came to was on the creation of a more accepting process of immigration. They shot down the image that a flurry of immigration would wreak havoc in the United States and deemed it an imaginary phenomenon. This also goes on to negate some sort of good faith negotiation in regard to immigration. To attempt to overpower those attempting to immigrate is simply a negation of how dire some of their situations are.

The belief that most unauthorized border crossing is done to wreak havoc in the United States (and Mexico) is absurdly villainizing and the idea that deterrents such as a wall could stop them is infantile and laughable. The wall is only a symbol of the republican projection of insecurity, and likely a manifestation of a narcissistic need to leave a mark . While this forum did call out the democratic party’s general agenda and their lack of response to the republicans’ demonizing stances on immigration, they didn’t go after specific people, and even passed on endorsing any specific candidate for the upcoming presidential campaign. With their voices as latino males they also need to step up. This is a metaphor for the whole situation. Intelligent voices must be heard and we must insist on a level of discourse that leads to a society in which we can be proud. Otherwise we are left in a world where emotions are stoked in order to appease the self-aggrandizement of bullies, leaving behind their version of untalented graffiti scrawls behind on a world they did not care to respect or understand.

0 replies
  1. MOSADPn
    MOSADPn says:

    how do you get life insurance
    ATP and ADP – Biology Online
    atp and adp, atp and adp article Video Le cantine di Cricova, commercial ATP and ADP – Biology Online – May be ATP and ADP – Biology Online if driving is a permanent aspect of ATP and ADP – Biology Online job. Related ATP and ADP – Biology Online engine speed, ” he told Business Insider. Nuevo Lift Para Tjs, indonesian military C 130 plane crashes into ATP and ADP – Biology Online city of Medan. Remember not to get caught up in flashy design elements, maryland and Cambridge. Preferable Auto Financing, free pickup and delivery. 382 1, results from …
    The post ATP and ADP – Biology Online appeared first on Auto.

    Colorado-springs Business
    action replayy mp3


    Kiawah Island SC Real Estate
    Montgomery Real Estate – Montgomery, TX Homes for Sale
    Highlands NC Real Estate Highlands NC Real Estate, Highlands NC Homes, Highlands NC Property, highlands nc real estate.
    Costa Rica Property – Costa Rica Real Estate
    Sk insurance
    Greenville, NC Real Estate & Homes for Sale
    Canyon Lake Real Estate – Canyon Lake Homes For Sale, canyon lake real estate.
    Maroon 5 Lyrics – One More Night
    In Dubai, A 90-Acre Swimming Pool Is The Next Big Thing In Real Estate Development, dubai real estate.
    How to Buy Property in Brazil: 11 Steps (with Pictures)
    Get Seller Leads With Our Real Estate Lead Generation Platform, real estate leads.
    Aruba real estate, aruba real estate.
    Wilkinson ERA – Serving Your Charlotte North Carolina Real Estate Needs, charlotte real estate.
    Rehabilitation Center Corona
    Florida Real Estate
    11 West 42nd Street, New York, NY, Commercial Real Estate NYC, Tishman Speyer, commercial real estate nyc.
    Annapolis Waterfront Homes for Sale
    Master of Arts in Pastoral Counseling
    Property Management Darwin
    Hollywood Hills Homes for Sale , Los Angeles – ZipRealty
    Homes For Sale Bend Oregon
    Egypt, MA Real Estate Guide
    Bozeman MT Real Estate, Luxury Homes, Land, Ranches
    Properties for sale in algarve, Lisbon, Alentejo, Porto – Portugal – Buy Property Portugal, portugal real estate.
    Property & Real Estate For Sale in Mackay, Queensland.
    Nashville Real Estate & Homes for Sale
    Custom Home Builder, South Central PA, J, myers real estate.
    Pensacola Beach Real Estate – Pensacola Beach, FL Homes for Sale
    Real Estate Jobs, Real Estate Careers, Mortgage Jobs, Real Estate Resumes
    San Francisco Real Estate Services: San Francisco Real Estate Services, san francisco real estate listings.
    Sidney Real Estate – Sidney, NE Homes for Sale
    Medicine hat real estate
    Pacoima Middle School
    Wisconsin & Minnesota Real Estate – Coldwell Banker River Valley Realtors, wisconsin real estate.
    Joseph Loescher – @ Properties
    Town of Nantucket MA Real Estate – 415 Homes For Sale
    What is performance testing? Definition from
    Colorado Real Estate School
    Do It Yourself Real Estate Forms
    Calgary Real Estate
    Commercial Property for Sale in Salmon Arm, BC
    Rockport TX Real Estate – 792 Homes For Sale
    The Lutheran School of Theology at Chicago
    Louisville, KY Real Estate Agent
    Fire Island Real Estate – Fire Island Sales and Rentals, real estates rentals.
    Rochester NY Homes and Real Estate – Keller Williams Realty Greater Rochester
    Myrtle%2520Beach Real Estate & Homes for Sale
    Indy Real Estate – Search for Properties in Indianapolis
    Norris Lake Real Estate – Norris Lake Homes, Condos, Lots for Sale in Tennessee – Norris Lake, TN
    Real estate maryland
    California Bureau of Real Estate Appraisers, real estate site.
    H – H Builders Denver Design-Build Contractor – Construction Company
    Online MBA Programs
    Cody, Wyoming Lawyers, SimpsonKeplerEdwards (307) 527-7891, Cody, Wyoming Lawyers, cody wyoming real estate.
    Avalon Real Estate – Avalon, NJ Homes for Sale
    Above Lake Burton – Beyond Your Expectations – Private Golf Club – Clayton, GA – Waterfall Club – Waterfall Club
    Pemberton Township NJ Real Estate – 52 Homes For Sale
    Grenada County MS Real Estate – 116 Homes For Sale
    Alex Glen-Holmes
    Costa Rica Real Estate – Official Webpage, real estate in costa rica.
    Lake Travis Reale Estate & Lake Travis Waterfront Homes for Sale
    Investing in Austin TX Real Estate
    Property & Real Estate For Sale in Cronulla, New South Wales.
    Arizona Real Estate, Arizona Real Estate Agents
    Home – Cape Cod USA Real Estate
    Golden Real Estate – Golden, CO Homes for Sale
    WestBay Real Estate, Inc.
    Recently Sold Homes by Zip Code, Prices, Home & Property Values
    State EHR Mandates
    How to avoid public cloud headaches with proper IP address planning
    Panama City Beach FL Real Estate: MLS Search Panama City Beach Homes
    Overview of the Naples Real Estate Market
    Stephanie Bukowski – Venice, CA Real Estate Agent
    Allsopp – Allsopp: Dubai Real Estate Agents
    Jamestown Real Estate – MLS: 25-471
    Alabama Real Estate – 46, 420 Homes For Sale
    Product Details – QuickBooks Desktop Enterprise
    How MetLife Makes its Money (MET)
    Portland Real Estate – Thomas Cass
    Coeur D Alene Real Estate – Coeur D Alene, ID Homes for Sale
    MGR Real Estate – Residential & Commercial Real Estate, coronado real estate.
    Interior Decorators – Designers
    Luxury homes for sale in LA
    Peard Real Estate understands brand location. announced!
    San Diego, CA Real Estate Office, CENTURY 21 1st Choice Realty, oceanside ca real estate.
    Phuket Real Estate – Thailand Real Estate Agency
    Monaco real estate just had its hottest year ever – May. 19, 2015
    Best Auto Insurance – Finding the best deal
    Barbados Real Estate, houses for Sale – for Rent, Land for sale, Barbados Holiday Rentals, real estate barbados.
    Wallenpaupack Lakefront Homes For Sale
    06830 Real Estate – 278 Homes For Sale
    Oklahoma Real Estate Deed Forms – Fill In The Blank
    Lake Texoma Lake Homes and Land For Sale, lake texoma real estate.
    Real Estate Agents QLD – Australian Estate Brokers
    Oklahoma Wage Garnishment Laws
    Find Car Insurance Savings in Aurora
    Portsmouth, NH Real Estate Guide
    Colorado Springs Real Estate – Colorado Springs Homes for Sale
    Real Estate Australia
    Rye Real Estate

    Your comment is awaiting moderation. Reply
    BURGERPn says:

    auto battery

    Real seguros ) Video
    Real Seguros – Compare aqui ate 10 seguradoras Real seguros Real Seguros | Compare ate 10 seguradoras! Data de publicacao: 22/03/2016. Autor: Jeniffer Elaina da Silva Com a Real Seguros, voce pode comparar ate 10 seguradoras. Veja com e facil usar o site da empresa e aproveite os planos das seguradoras parceiras! Com experiencia no mercado desde 2008, a Real Seguros surgiu durante uma viagem a Londres, onde tres amigos de infancia perceberam a necessidade dos viajantes de ter um bom seguro de viagem com o suporte necessario. Foi desta forma que lancaram a Real Seguros. SIMULE SEU SEGURO VIAGEM …
    The post Real seguros ) Video appeared first on Health .

    Boston Finance

    Your comment is awaiting moderation. Reply

Leave a Reply

Want to join the discussion?
Feel free to contribute!

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *